![]()
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
A review of emerging flea-borne bacterial pathogens in
New Zealand
Patrick Kelly, Sally Roberts, Pierre-Edouard Fournier
Fleas are the vectors of emerging and re-emerging bacterial
pathogens. Four such pathogens are known to occur in New Zealand;
Rickettsia typhi,
R. felis,
Bartonella henselae, and
B. clarridgeiae. To raise awareness of
these emerging pathogens among New Zealand health workers, in this review we
describe the clinical features, diagnosis and treatment of infections and the
biology of the major flea vectors.
Flea-borne bacterial pathogensRickettsia typhiThis
is an obligate intracellular Gram-negative bacterium that is the agent of
murine or endemic typhus. The disease occurs world-wide and is increasingly
being recognised in travellers, and in people in Australia, parts of the United
States and more recently in New
Zealand.1–3 The major vector of
R. typhi is the oriental rat flea,
Xenopsylla cheopis, in which the
organism multiplies in the midgut and is excreted in the faeces where it remains
viable for years.4 Although
X. cheopis can transmit
R. typhi by
biting,5 infections usually result from
inhalation or ingestion of infected flea faeces or inoculation of faeces into
pruritic flea bite lesions. Rattus rats
are the main reservoir hosts and animals of all ages are highly susceptible to
infections, which persist for 2 to 3 weeks but cause no ill-effects.
Clinical
manifestations—Rickettsiae multiply in the vascular endothelium and
induce vascular injury, which accounts for most of the clinicopathologic
findings. Patients with murine typhus have non-specific signs including fever,
headache, myalgia, and a non-specific maculopapular rash.6 The disease is seen
more commonly in adults but also occurs in children. Laboratory abnormalities
include elevated liver enzymes, thrombocytopenia, and mild leucopenia.
Diagnosis—The
majority of cases of murine typhus go undiagnosed (as clinical signs are
non-specific).6 Definitive diagnosis of
infections depends on a high level of suspicion of the disease by physicians and
confirmatory laboratory tests. Serological testing for rickettsial infection
using an immunofluorescence assay is performed at LabPlus, Auckland District
Health Board. Cross-reactivity can occur with other bacteria and this may lead
to difficulties with interpreting results.7,8
Nucleic acid amplification testing on whole blood by PCR using primers for the
17 kDa protein and citrate synthase gene is also available. Culture is not
routinely performed.
Treatment—Patients
respond rapidly to treatment with tetracycline, doxycycline or a
fluoroquinolone. Untreated patients show signs for two to three weeks and a
significant number are hospitalised, with up to 10% requiring intensive care.
Rickettsia felisPreviously known as the ELB agent,
this is a recently described Gram-negative obligate intracellular bacteria which
is a member of the spotted fever group (SFG)
rickettsiae.9 Although only recognised for a
short time, R. felis has already been
found in the USA,1 Brazil, Germany, Spain,
France, Ethiopia, United Kingdom, Thailand and, most recently, New
Zealand.10
While ticks are the principal reservoirs and vectors of the
SFG rickettsiae, R. felis is maintained
in nature by the cat flea, Ctenocephalides
felis. Up to 93% of commercial cat fleas are
infected,1 but the prevalence is lower in
wild-caught fleas and is 10% in New Zealand.10
R. felis is transmitted transovarially
by C. felis which can maintain
infections for at least 12 generations without feeding on an infected
host.11 R.
felis seems to be transmitted by flea
bites12 but flea faeces contain viable
organisms and transmission might occur with faecal inoculation into pruritic
flea bites.
Clinical
manifestations—While infections in cats appear to be subclinical,
people infected with R. felis may
develop severe signs, presumably as organisms multiply in the vascular
endothelium. The first case of “flea-borne spotted fever” occurred
in Texas in 1994 but patients have now been described in Mexico (3), Brazil (2),
Germany (2), France (2), and Thailand (1).13
Mostly, there is no history of recent contact with fleas and clinical signs are
non-specific, most commonly including fever, headache and rash. Other signs
include marked fatigue, myalgia, photophobia, conjunctivitis, abdominal pain,
vomiting, and diarrhoea—as well as solitary, black crusted skin lesions
surrounded by a livid halo. Laboratory abnormalities are similar to those seen
with murine typhus.
Diagnosis—Diagnoses
of infections have been made by PCR and sequencing of DNA extracted from blood
or skin biopsy samples using primers for the 17 kDa
protein14,15, citrate
synthase15,16 and PS 120
protein17 genes found in rickettsiae Recently,
R. felis has been established in tissue
culture (XTC-2 and Vero cells) and this has enabled serological testing which
appears to be reliable and has been used to diagnose
infections.16 Serology and PCR for
R. felis is available at LabPlus,
Auckland District Health Board.
Treatment—Patients
have been successfully treated with
doxycycline.17
In vitro studies have shown
R. felis is sensitive to doxycycline,
rifampin, thiamphenicol, and fluoroquinolones—but not to gentamicin,
erythromycin, amoxicillin, or cotrimoxazole.
Bartonella henselaeThis Gram-negative bacillus was
first described in 1993. The domestic cat is the major reservoir of infection
and around 10% to 40% of cats have chronic
bacteremia,18 which may persist for years. Most
infected cats appear healthy but can infect people through scratches, bites, and
licks of open wounds. The cat flea, C.
felis, also transmits infections, by feeding or when infected flea faeces
are inoculated into skin wounds caused by pruritic fleabites. There is some
evidence that B. henselae is
transmitted by ticks but we have not found organisms in ticks in New Zealand
(Kelly P, unpublished data, 2004).
Although B. henselae
was first recognised as an agent of bacillary angiomatosis in AIDS
patients, the organism is now known to cause a wide variety of other disease
syndromes. The nature and severity of the conditions correlate with the immune
status of the patient—those with intact or only immature immune systems
develop more localised infections, while immunocompromised patients (e.g. AIDS
patients) often develop systemic infections which may be fatal.
Clinical
manifestations—Bartonelloses are suspected to be the most common
bacterial zoonoses acquired from companion animals.
B.
henselae is the major etiological agent of CSD which is probably the most
common cause of chronic, benign, lymphadenopathy in children and young adults in
developed countries.19 The initial lesion
consists of a papule, pustule or vesicle that develops 2 to 3 weeks after a cat
bite or scratch, usually on the arms.20
Although the initial lesion heals uneventfully, regional lymphadenopathy (the
hallmark of the disease) develops 1 week later and persists for 2 weeks to 3
months before resolving spontaneously. In 75% of patients the adenopathy occurs
with mild systemic symptoms including fever, malaise, fatigue, headache,
anorexia, weight loss, and emesis that usually resolve within 2 weeks. Enlarged
lymph nodes can be tender, and up to 20% of these nodes suppurate. Most cases
are self-limiting with the adenopathy resolving spontaneously in 2 to 4 months.
Atypical manifestations of CSD
occur in about 15% of patients. The most common is Parinaud’s
occuloglandular syndrome where there is unilateral conjunctivitis with
pre-auricular lymphadenopathy that probably results from inoculation into the
conjunctiva rather than the skin. In some patients, dissemination of the
organism can occur to cause granulomas or abscesses in the liver, spleen, bone,
or mesenteric lymph nodes. Systemic manifestations of CSD include
hepatosplenomegaly, glomerulonephritis, and pleural
effusion.19 Various neurological syndromes have
been reported with CSD including generalised seizures, transverse myelitis,
encephalopathy, neuroretinitis, facial nerve paresis, and peripheral
neuritis.21,22
Bacillary
angiomatosis is a potentially fatal pseudoneoplastic vascular
proliferative disease that occurs principally in immunocompromised patients,
particularly those in the later stages of HIV
infection.23
There is considerable evidence that infections result from contact with
cats.
Although the skin is most
commonly affected, there may be osseous, gastrointestinal, respiratory, lymph
node, central nervous system, and bone marrow bacillary angiomatosis (with or
without accompanying skin lesions). In the skin, bacillary angiomatosis usually
presents clinically as erythematous papules and
nodules that may be
localised or diffuse and bleed profusely when punctured. They may mimic
Kaposi's sarcoma in appearance. In the disseminated forms of bacillary
angiomatosis there may be fever, weight loss, and enlargement of the affected
organs.
Bacillary peliosis is a very rare
condition caused by B. henselae
infection of parenchymal vasculature which results in development of cystic,
blood-filled spaces in the liver, spleen, or lymph
nodes.24 The disease is associated with
immunosuppression and traumatic exposure to cats.
Recent
studies have shown B. henselae is a
cause of fever in HIV-infected people that might not be associated with
lymphadenopathy or hepatosplenic involvement.25
In a recent report from South Africa, 10% of people attending an HIV clinic were
found to be PCR positive for B.
henselae.26 In HIV-uninfected patients
(regardless of whether they are immunocompetent or pharmacologically
immunosuppressed), B. henselae may
cause an acute onset of febrile illness with arthralgia, myalgia, and headaches
which may persist or become relapsing. In some patients,
B. henselae infections result in
long-term asymptomatic persistent bacteraemia. Contact with cats is a major risk
factor for B. henselae
bacteraemia.25
Endocarditis
due to B. henselae occurs most often in
patients with pre-existing valvulopathies who have contact with cats and their
fleas.27 The mortality rate is high (25%) and
most patients require valve replacement surgery.
Diagnosis—There
are no pathognomonic clinical features of B.
henselae infections, and definitive diagnoses can only be made using
laboratory testing. Histology of biopsy samples may provide a presumptive
diagnosis, particularly if organisms are demonstrated within characteristic
lesions with Warthin-Starry silver impregnation staining. Immunocytochemical
techniques are used to detect B.
henselae in tissue sections and cytological specimens in specialised
laboratories.28
B. henselae can be
cultured on most blood-enriched media, but primary isolates are usually only
observed after 12 to 14 days of culture, sometimes as long as 45
days.29 Lysis-centrifugation or freeze-thawing
of blood samples greatly increases the recovery of organisms. Cultures from
immunocompetent people and those previously treated with antibiotics are often
negative. Identification of isolates is
difficult using standard bacteriological methods and is best accomplished using
molecular methods which are also sensitive and specific tests for detecting
organisms in tissues and blood.29 A variety of
primers have been used in PCR analyses, including those against regions of the
16SrRNA, 17-kDa antigen, and citrate synthase
(gltA) genes and the 16S/23S intragenic
spacer region.30,31
Serology is a cheap, sensitive, and safe means of supporting
clinical diagnoses of Bartonella
infections, in particular endocarditis27 and
CSD.28 Serological cross-reactivity occurs
between Bartonella spp. and tests
should be performed against all species known to occur in an area before an
etiological diagnosis is made. Generally, highest titres are against the species
causing the infection. Immunocompromised patients might not mount significant
antibody responses. Culture, PCR, and serology for
B. henselae are available in New
Zealand.
Treatment—In
vitro, B. henselae is
susceptible to most antibiotics although only aminoglycosides are
bactericidal.32 Most typical cases of CSD,
however, respond very poorly to antimicrobial therapy and the disease generally
resolves spontaneously within 4 months.33
Although treatment with azithromycin has been suggested for patients with
pronounced lymphadenopathy, no therapeutic advantage has been
demonstrated.34 There is debate as to whether
patients with complicated CSD benefit from
antibiotics.35 In immunocompromised patients
with CSD or immunocompetent patients with central nervous system involvement, a
combination of doxycycline and rifampin has been suggested but there is little
data to support the recommendation.35 In
patients with suppurative lymph nodes, needle aspiration is an appropriate
treatment.
The currently recommended treatment for bacillary
angiomatosis and peliosis hepatis is oral erythromycin. Most HIV positive
patients with bacillary angiomatosis respond well to antibiotics with complete
remissions in 65% of patients within 30 days of
treatment.23 Relapses may occur when short
(<15 days) courses of treatment are given.
Successful therapy for bartonella endocarditis usually
entails replacement of the extensively damaged valve. The optimum antibiotic
treatment is not known, but the use of gentamicin with a beta-lactam has been
recommended.36
Bartonella clarridgeiaeThis organism was first described in
199637 after it was isolated from the cat of an
HIV-positive patient with CSD due to B.
henselae. The cat is the reservoir of the organism and up to 12% of cats
might have concurrent B. henselae
infections. The vectors of B.
clarridgeiae are unknown, but cat fleas infected with the organism have
been found in France, the Netherlands, the Philippines, Indonesia, and now
New Zealand.10 Fleas containing DNA of
both R. felis and
B. clarridgeiae have been found in
France.
Clinical
manifestations—Serological testing has indicated
B. clarridgeiae might be an agent of
CSD in people.38 In dogs, the organism has been
implicated as an agent of hepatitis and endocarditis.
Diagnosis—The
organism can be cultured on solid media and detected by PCR and
sequencing.39
Treatment—There
is no reliable data on appropriate treatment.
FleasFleas are insects in the order
Siphonaptera that have a number of developmental stages in their life cycle. The
adults live permanently on the host and feed on its blood. The immature stages
develop in the environment and feed on organic debris. The cat flea,
C. felis, is the most important
ectoparasite of domestic cats and dogs in New Zealand and world-wide. It has a
wide host range—readily feeding on people, pets, domestic animals, wild
mammals, and rodents.40 Adults can reproduce
for up to 3 months and females lay up to 50 eggs per day, which hatch in the
environment and develop to pupae in as little as 10 days. Adult fleas may remain
in the cocoon for many months before emerging in response to vibration and/or
heat. The adults are non-selective feeders and are attracted to their hosts by
visual and thermal cues. People are mainly bitten by newly emerging adults;
direct transfer of fleas between hosts is uncommon.
The main host of the oriental rat flea,
X.
cheopis, are
Rattus rats but sometimes they occur on
the house mouse, Mus musculus. The
number of eggs laid per day varies with the species of the host but is less than
with C. felis. As with the cat flea,
pupae can survive many months of starvation while awaiting a host.
Current information on flea-borne bacterial pathogens in New ZealandTo date, only infections with
R. typhi and
B. henselae have been diagnosed in
people in New Zealand. Locally acquired murine typhus due to
R. typhi was first reported in
1991.3 Subsequently, 20 patients from the
greater Auckland region have been diagnosed with the disease (unpublished data,
S Roberts). The majority of patients lived in northwest Auckland around the
Kaipara Harbour, but three cases have occurred in the Coromandel Peninsula
region. It is highly likely that it is present in other regions throughout New
Zealand, especially those close to current or historic ports.
R. typhi DNA has been detected by PCR
in rats captured on the properties of two patients but not in fleas obtained
from rats or domestic animals.2,10
Two patients infected with
B. henselae have been reported in New
Zealand; both had neuroretinitis22 and one also
had encephalopathy.21 DNA of
B. henselae has been identified in the
lymph nodes of 3 patients with suspected CSD (unpublished data, S Roberts).
Also, the organism has been isolated from 17% of cats in
Auckland, and has been identified in 3%
of cat fleas collected from dogs and cats presenting to the Veterinary Teaching
Hospital of Massey University in Palmerston
North.10
In nearby Australia, there have also been relatively few
reports of clinical cases of
B. henselae infections, although
5% of blood donors are seropositive and 35% of cats from Sydney are
bacteremic.41 While infections may be
under-reported, recent genotyping studies have shown there is a high level of
diversity amongst strains of B. henselae
and those isolated from people
are more genotypically homogeneous than those associated with feline
reservoirs.18 There might, then, be specific
genotypes that are more likely to cause clinical infections in people and
further studies are indicated to determine the types present in New
Zealand.
R. felis and
B. clarridgeiae have only recently been
reported to occur in their vectors in New
Zealand,10 and there have been no reports of
human infections.
Prevention of infectionsPrevention of infections with
flea-borne bacterial pathogens is best achieved by minimising contact with the
vectors and reservoirs of the organisms. In the case of
R. typh, steps should be taken to
eliminate rodents in the household. Rodent fleas (particularly
X. cheopis) must be controlled
simultaneously, otherwise outbreaks of murine typhus will occur after the rats
die and their fleas seek alternative hosts.
Prevention of infections with
B. henselae,
B.
clarridgeiae, and
R. felis is best achieved by control of
their cat flea vector. Veterinary advice should be sought on the variety of
highly effective products, which can eliminate cat fleas from the household and
are readily available in New Zealand. Bacteremic cats may also be a source of
infection with direct transmission resulting from bites and scratches. Although
these cats can be identified by blood cultures, no single antibiotic or
combination of antibiotics can reliably eliminate infections from cats. While
infected animals can be removed from a household, cats play an important role in
improving the quality of life of their owners, particularly children and
immunosuppressed people.
Therefore, rather than families being deprived of their
cats, the risk of infection can be greatly decreased by instituting effective
flea-control strategies and preventing situations where scratches or bites are
likely to occur, such as with rough play or during teasing.
A vaccine against B.
henselae for cats has been reported but subsequent studies have shown
lack of protection following infection and challenge with the different strains
of the organism.42
ConclusionsThe development of new culture and
molecular biology techniques has facilitated the investigation of flea-borne
bacterial diseases of people. Application of these techniques in New Zealand has
shown that R. typhi and pathogenic
Bartonella species are present in the
country and that infections occur in people. Also, the pathogenic flea-borne SFG
rickettsia, R. felis, has been shown to
occur in relatively high proportions of cat fleas. Health workers in New Zealand
should, then, be aware of the possibility of infections with these organisms in
their patients and diagnostic laboratories in the region should provide
appropriate diagnostic tests.
Author information:
Patrick Kelly, Professor, Ross University School of Veterinary Medicine,
Basseterre, St Kitts, West Indies; Sally Roberts, Senior Microbiologist,
Department of Microbiology, Auckland District Health Board, Auckland;
Pierre-Edouard Fournier, Physician, Unité des Rickettsies,
Faculté de Médecine, Marseille, France
Correspondence:
Patrick Kelly, Ross University School of Veterinary Medicine, PO Box 334,
Basseterre, St Kitts, West Indies. Fax: +869 465 1203; email: pkelly@rossvet.edu.kn
References:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Current
issue | Search journal |
Archived issues | Classifieds
| Hotline (free ads) Subscribe | Contribute | Advertise | Contact Us | Copyright | Other Journals |